Print

Mediterranean Diet Research Deeply Flawed

This is a great "let's get real" article.

It addresses the 9 point scoring system created by the promoters of the mediterranean diet.

First of all, all the factors for health and the success of a particular diet cannot be summarized into 9 points. Next, these nine factors have to do with diet and exercise as if these are the only fundamentals of successful living, they are not. Third, read this article...

Here are a few of the article highlights:

  • First of all, it concerns itself only with quantities of specific things, not quality. So nutrient-poor industrialized, toxin-compromised foods are given the same score as organic and nutrient-rich foods free from toxins.
  • Second, Mediterranean Diet research assumes that only diet, or only diet and exercise are factors in the superior health and longer lifespans of Mediterranean people, but as other research is showing, sunshine is another factor. This is a problem because Mediterranean diet research does not include advice to get more sun.
  • Third, with the exception of alcohol and saturated fats, the Mediterranean Diet Scale doesn't concern itself with consumption or over consumption of unhealthy foods. So it's possible to get a perfect 9 on the Mediterranean diet scale, and still consume huge amounts of cotton candy and Red Bull and every day.
  • Fourth, subjects get an alcohol point for consuming from one to three glasses of alcohol for men and slightly less for women. That means drinking zero alcohol -- the healthiest option, assuming the rest of your diet is healthy -- is treated the same as drinking a bottle of scotch every day. The upper end of this scale -- three glasses per day -- is enough to develop chronic alcoholism.
1 Comment
  1. at 9:04 pm on November 3, 2009

    It is not the food as much as what the food is laced with.I lived in the Caribbean where we had all the land we needed to plant our own fruit and vegetables. This is of course without the pesticides that is in the fruits and vegetables in the stores today. They claim all these chemicals is to preserve and slow down the ripping process for shipping purposes.
    Maybe its better than having no fruit and vegetables,but we cant rely on only that to get what our body needs we need supplements and herbs.This is just my own opinion the subject.

Leave a Reply

  1. *Required
  2. *Required (will not be published)

You might also like:

About the Author

John Allen Mollenhauer (also known as John Allen or "JAM") is the founder of NutrientRich.com. After years of eating the Standard American Diet, gaining weight and defaulting to weight loss-only diets that were unhealthy and unsustainable, and finally learning why people don't get the results they want eating "half-baked healthier diets" that can also keep you stuck in a vicious cycle of eating nutrient poor; he finally made the Switch to Rich-- The Nutrient Rich Healthy Eating Style that ensures you can get all the success results you want. Discover the 90% or More Plant Based Nutrient Rich® approach and optimize the way you eat for nutrient density.